Carpal Tunnel Syndrome – Is Surgery The Only Answer?

Carpal tunnel syndrome causes tingling, numbness, pain, and wasting of the muscles on the thumb side of the hand – the area that is supplied by the median nerve.

Surgery is often recommended as the best treatment. However, it is a serious undertaking, and sometimes a more conservative approach might be better. To know what route to take, we first need to have a good understanding of the different causes of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome.

The carpal tunnel is formed by an arch of four bones, the carpal bones, which form the back of the wrist. The front of the wrist is formed by the flexor retinaculum, a strong ligament which spans the arch. The tunnel thus forms between them.

Through this tunnel pass a number of crucial structures, including the tendons that bend the fingers, and the median nerve. With Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, this nerve gets squeezed and compressed. The result is a decrease in its conductivity, meaning the nerve does not function as it should.

This nerve innervates the palm side of the hand over the thumb and first three and a half fingers. It also innervates the backs of the fingertips over this same area. Therefore, compression of the median nerve can only result in irritation over this area of the hand. If the trouble area is over the back of the hand or over the little finger, it is not carpal tunnel syndrome.

It is ultimately the compression of the median nerve that leads to carpal tunnel syndrome. Medical testing for carpal tunnel syndrome usually entails the use of an electromyelogram (EMG).

The EMG is done by putting a probe on the nerve in the forearm and again in the hand. A small current is then passed between the two of them to see how good the conduction is. A decrease in conduction means Carpal Tunnel Syndrome.

The surgery for this condition would then include cutting some of the flexor retinaculum to allow less pressure on the median nerve by essentially expanding the carpal tunnel. This procedure may often help to decrease the symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome, but is it the only option? Absolutely not.

So what causes Carpal Tunnel Syndrome? The first common cause is a deterioration of the joints between the carpal bones. This causes the tunnel to collapse and, in turn, compresses the median nerve. The second cause is a swelling of the tendons. The enlarged tendons take up more space, and so put pressure on the nerve.

The problem with using solely EMG to determine the presence of carpal tunnel syndrome is that it doesn’t differentiate between the two causes. This leads to a lack of differentiation of treatment which may, in turn, result in unnecessary surgery.

If the problem is arising from tendonitis, I believe it is much better to treat the tendonitis. The way tendonitis occurs is from having too much strain or tension placed on the tendon for too long of a time.

Too much repetitive use of the muscles in the forearm cause them to tighten up. This then makes the tendons tight too, and that can cause them to become inflamed and swollen – a common cause of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome.

In this case, using treatments such as stretching, physiotherapy, nutritional support, soft tissue manipulation, good typing posture, and chiropractic manipulation can be effective. And much less invasive with fewer side effects than surgery.

This does not mean that surgery is not a viable option. My preferred method, of course, is to begin with the least invasive form of therapy. If these options do not bring relief of symptoms, then surgery can be looked at.